What are the disadvantages of using a queen excluder? Key Drawbacks Beekeepers Should Know

While queen excluders offer significant benefits in hive management, they also come with notable drawbacks that beekeepers should consider. These devices can disrupt natural bee behaviors, cause physical harm to drones and workers, and create management challenges like honeybound brood nests. Understanding these disadvantages helps beekeepers make informed decisions about whether and how to use excluders in their apiaries.

Key Points Explained:

1. Disruption of Natural Bee Behavior

   • Queen excluders forcibly separate honey storage from brood rearing, which doesn't occur in wild hives. This artificial division can:
     • Conflict with bees' natural tendency to intersperse honey and brood cells
     • Potentially stress the colony by restricting movement patterns
     • Reduce hive efficiency as workers must navigate the barrier repeatedly

2. Physical Harm to Bees

   • Drones: Larger drone bees frequently get stuck in excluder gaps while attempting to pass through, leading to:
     • Trapped drones dying of starvation or dehydration
     • Workers wasting time trying to free stuck drones
     • Reduced drone population affecting mating success
   • Workers: Constant passage through the excluder can:
     • Wear down or damage worker bees' wings over time
     • Shorten worker lifespans due to physical stress
     • Create traffic jams at the excluder during peak activity

3. Honeybound Brood Nest Risk

   • The physical barrier may cause bees to:
     • Overfill the brood chamber with honey (honeybound)
     • Restrict the queen's laying space, reducing colony growth
     • Require frequent human intervention to:
       • Rotate honey-filled combs out of brood area
       • Add empty combs for queen laying
       • Monitor space balance carefully

4. Increased Management Complexity

   • Using excluders demands more attentive hive management through:
     • Regular inspections to prevent space issues
     • Additional comb manipulation
     • Careful timing of excluder placement/removal
     • Potential need for stronger colonies to overcome barrier effects
   • Novice beekeepers may find this added complexity challenging

5. Potential Productivity Impacts

   • Some evidence suggests excluders may:
     • Temporarily reduce honey production as bees adjust
     • Cause bees to sometimes ignore supers above the excluder
     • Require stronger nectar flows to motivate bees to work through the barrier

These disadvantages don't necessarily outweigh the benefits, but they highlight why some experienced beekeepers choose to use excluders selectively or not at all. The decision often depends on specific hive goals, local conditions, and the beekeeper's management style. Have you considered how these factors might interact with your particular beekeeping operation?

Summary Table:

Need help choosing the right hive management tools for your apiary? Contact HONESTBEE—we supply commercial beekeepers and distributors with premium equipment tailored to your operational needs.