In beekeeping, a queen excluder is a physical barrier used to confine the queen bee to the brood-rearing area of the hive. It is a perforated sheet, typically made of metal or plastic, with openings large enough for worker bees to pass through but too small for the larger queen and drones. In a horizontal hive, this piece of equipment is considered unnecessary because the queen naturally self-restricts her egg-laying to a consolidated area, leaving outer frames for pure honey storage.
The need for a queen excluder arises directly from the design of a vertical hive, which forces bees to expand upward against their instincts. Horizontal hives, by contrast, work with the colony's natural tendency to expand outward, making an artificial barrier to separate brood from honey redundant.
The Role of the Queen Excluder in Vertical Hives
In modern beekeeping, the primary goal of a queen excluder is to make honey harvesting cleaner and more efficient. This is especially critical in the most common type of hive, the vertical Langstroth hive.
The Problem: Mixing Brood and Honey
A queen bee’s job is to lay eggs, which develop into brood (larvae and pupae). Beekeepers want to harvest frames that contain only honey, not a mixture of honey, pollen, and developing bees. Harvesting frames with brood is messy and results in the loss of the next generation of bees.
The Vertical Hive Solution
In a vertical hive, the colony is housed in a stack of boxes. The bottom box (or two) is designated as the brood chamber, where the queen lays her eggs. Boxes added on top are called honey supers, intended only for honey storage.
A queen excluder is placed directly on top of the brood chamber. This acts as a ceiling for the queen, preventing her from moving up and laying eggs in the honey supers. The smaller worker bees easily pass through it to deposit nectar.
How Beekeepers Introduce an Excluder
To encourage bees to move up through the excluder, a beekeeper will often take a frame of sealed brood from the brood chamber and place it in the center of the honey super above. The nurse bees will move up to care for the brood, drawing the rest of the foragers and workers into the new space.
Why Horizontal Hives Make it Obsolete
Horizontal hives, such as Top Bar or Layens hives, are managed with a different philosophy that more closely mimics a bee colony's natural development in a fallen log or cavity.
Understanding the Bee's Natural Nest
In nature, a bee colony creates a specific nest structure. They establish a central, spherical brood nest. This core is immediately surrounded by a ring of pollen, which is then surrounded by an outer arch of stored honey.
As the colony grows, this entire structure expands outward, not upward. The brood nest remains a consolidated sphere, and new honey is stored on the periphery.
Horizontal Hives Mirror Natural Behavior
A horizontal hive is essentially a long, single-story box. The bees establish their brood nest in the center frames. As the season progresses and the nectar flow begins, they don't need to be forced upward. Instead, they simply expand the nest horizontally.
The queen instinctively stays within the warm, dense cluster of the brood nest. She is naturally "hemmed in" by the surrounding stores of pollen and honey, creating a functional boundary without a physical barrier. The frames at the far ends of the hive will, by nature, be used exclusively for honey.
Understanding the Trade-offs
While horizontal hives render excluders unnecessary for their primary purpose, the device still has specific applications and consequences that are important to understand.
The Argument for Using Excluders
Commercial beekeepers often value predictability and speed. Using an excluder—even in a system where it isn't strictly needed—provides a 100% guarantee that the queen is not in the honey supers. This allows for rapid removal of honey frames without the risk of accidentally removing and losing the queen.
The Drawbacks of an Excluder
The primary downside is that an excluder can act as a bottleneck, slowing down worker bees as they move between the brood nest and honey stores. This friction can potentially reduce the hive's overall honey production. Some beekeepers also observe that colonies can become "honey bound"—filling the brood chamber with nectar because they are reluctant to cross the barrier.
A Critical Winter Warning
A queen excluder must be removed after the final honey harvest and before winter. As temperatures drop, the bee cluster will move upward to consume its honey stores. If an excluder is left in place, the cluster can move above it, leaving the queen trapped below to freeze and die.
Making the Right Choice for Your Goal
Ultimately, your equipment should align with your hive design and management philosophy.
- If your primary focus is managing a vertical (Langstroth) hive: Using a queen excluder is standard and effective practice for ensuring clean honey supers and simplifying your harvest.
- If your primary focus is managing a horizontal (Top Bar/Layens) hive: A queen excluder is unnecessary, as the colony's natural behavior will effectively separate the brood nest from honey stores.
- If your primary focus is maximum efficiency at a commercial scale: An excluder can be a useful tool to guarantee queen location and speed up honey harvesting, regardless of hive type.
By understanding how hive design influences bee behavior, you can choose tools that work with your bees' instincts, not against them.
Summary Table:
| Hive Type | Queen Excluder Needed? | Key Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Vertical (e.g., Langstroth) | Yes | Artificially separates brood chamber from honey supers in a stacked design. |
| Horizontal (e.g., Top Bar, Layens) | No | Queen naturally restricts brood to the center; honey is stored on the outer frames. |
Ready to equip your apiary with the right tools for your hive design?
At HONESTBEE, we supply commercial apiaries and beekeeping equipment distributors with high-quality, durable supplies through our wholesale-focused operations. Whether you manage vertical hives and need reliable queen excluders or are building out a horizontal hive system, we have the equipment to support your success and maximize honey production.
Contact HONESTBEE today to discuss your specific needs and place a wholesale order!
Visual Guide
Related Products
- Premium Wood Framed Metal Wire Queen Bee Excluder
- High Performance Plastic Queen Excluder for Beekeeping and Apiary Management
- Professional Plastic Queen Excluder for Modern Beekeeping
- Plastic Queen Bee Excluder for Bee Hive Wholesale
- Wooden Queen Bee Excluder for Beekeeping
People Also Ask
- When to put queen excluder on hive? Key Timing for Maximum Honey Production
- Where should a queen excluder be placed in a beehive? The Key to Hive Organization
- What makes polyurethane foam environmentally friendly? The Surprising Benefits of a Durable, Inert Material
- What are the advantages of using queen excluders? Boost Honey Production & Hive Management
- What considerations should a beekeeper take into account when deciding whether to use an excluder?
