Using 9 frames in a 10-frame hive is a common practice among beekeepers for several practical reasons. This approach allows bees to draw out the comb more fully, making it easier to uncap during honey extraction. It also simplifies hive management by reducing the risk of rolling the queen and minimizing the need for additional equipment. However, there are potential downsides, such as encouraging excess drone cells or brace combing. Overall, this method offers a balance between ease of management and efficient honey production.

Key Points Explained:

1. Easier Uncapping of Honey Frames:

   • When 9 frames are used in a 10-frame hive, the bees draw out the comb more fully. This thicker comb makes it easier to uncap during honey extraction, especially when using an uncapping machine. The reduced spacing between frames ensures that the comb is drawn out farther, which simplifies the uncapping process and reduces the need for additional tools like capping scratchers.

2. Reduced Risk of Rolling the Queen:

   • Using a follower to space the frames in a 9-frame setup reduces the risk of accidentally rolling the queen when inspecting or managing the hive. This is particularly important in brood boxes, where the queen’s safety is crucial for colony health and productivity.

3. Simplified Equipment Management:

   • By standardizing on 9 frames in a 10-frame box, beekeepers can avoid the need for separate 9-frame and 10-frame boxes. This simplifies equipment management and reduces the complexity of maintaining different types of hives.

4. Encourages Fuller Comb Drawing:

   • The reduced number of frames encourages bees to draw the comb out more fully. This not only makes uncapping easier but also results in more uniform comb, which can be beneficial for both honey production and brood rearing.

5. Potential Negative Effects:

   • Excess Drone Cells: The extra space can encourage bees to build more drone cells, which may not be desirable in all situations.
   • Brace or Cross Combing: Improper spacing can lead to brace or cross combing, making hive management more difficult.
   • Gumming Up of Metal Braces: The extra space can also serve as a hiding spot for small hive beetles (SHB) and may gum up metal braces.
   • Reduced Brood Production: In early spring, fewer cells may be covered by bees, potentially affecting colony buildup.

6. Issues with Improper Spacing:

   • If frames are not properly spaced, bees may drop comb between the frames, creating a messy and difficult-to-manage super. Additionally, undrawn frames placed too far apart may result in bees building foundationless comb in the extra space, complicating extraction.

7. Comparison with Other Configurations:

   • 8 Frames in a 10-Frame Super: This configuration reduces the number of frames to uncap and spin during honey harvesting, making the process easier. It also encourages bees to draw comb farther out, which simplifies uncapping.
   • 11 Frames in a 10-Frame Box: This setup provides an extra frame for brood and keeps the brood closer together, making it easier for bees to keep the brood warm. However, it requires cutting down the width of standard frames to fit.
   • 9 Frames in an 8-Frame Box: This can make the hive very tight, especially as propolis builds up, and may lead to issues with burr comb if the frames are not properly spaced or managed.

By understanding these key points, beekeepers can make informed decisions about frame configuration in their hives, balancing ease of management with efficient honey production and colony health.

Summary Table:

Want to optimize your hive setup? Contact our experts today for personalized advice!